Wednesday, August 28, 2024

Ranking Hitchcock's 1930s films

Note: Elstree Calling (1930) was only partially directed by Hitchcock and as Hitch himself said, it's of no interest whatsoever apart from a glimpse into British music hall. 

Juno and the Paycock (1930) - I couldn't find English subtitles for this so I had to follow along with a copy of Seán O'Casey's play which was no fun. No catastrophe but I'm struggling to discover a reason why anyone would need to see this beyond completism. B-minus

The Skin Game (1931) - A Hatfields and McCoys melodrama as nasty as anything in Hitchcock's oeuvre. But the film comes alive only in the auction scene. Everywhere else, Hitch seems bored. At times, he can't even be bothered to pan or track over to a character talking. Scholars of offscreen voices should thus derive more use value out of this than the rest of us. B-minus

Waltzes from Vienna (1933) - Reviewed here. Much better than its rep but forgettable. B

Jamaica Inn (1939) - Included in The Fifty Worst Films of All Time. But it's actually quite fun. It would've been even more fun had it not been so indifferently directed. But producer/star Charles Laughton exerted far too much control. And maybe Hitchcock's heart was already in Hollywood when he took on this final project before leaving to fulfill his contract with David O. Selznick in April, 1939. Sexy bastard: Emlyn Williams as Harry the Pedlar. B+

Number Seventeen (1932) - A fascinating mess. It's a film of verticals with people falling through roofs and hanging from broken balustrades in the tall haunted house of the title. It ends with a bus speeding to catch up with a runaway train which slams into a ferry and, in a premonition of Lifeboat (1944), sends all the cars into the water. Silly, nonsensical, but only 63 minutes! B+

Secret Agent (1936) - Where looks in Hitchcock's oeuvre are menacing or duplicitous, here sound oppresses - an organ note held by a dead body on the keyboard; a deafening bell necessitating John Gielgud to shout in Peter Lorre's ear; a dog's gut-wrenching howl upon its owner's wrongful murder; a coin circling a ceramic bowl in an increasingly dissonant (Bulgarian?) folk song; a roaring chocolate factory; soldiers incessantly singing on a train; and yet another train wreck with all the attendant explosions and earth rattles. But I wish Hitch kept the play of identities in motion instead of ending with the (admittedly and blessedly brief) formation of the heterosexual couple. P. S. Is that toilet paper in the screenshot below?!? B+

Murder! (1930)/Mary (1931) - The overly narrative whodunit aspect (what I call the "well, she put her left shoe on her right foot so she must be the killer" school of storytelling) does this one in. What takes up two lines of synopsis on Wiki takes 30 minutes of running time in the film (and I'm being lenient here). And while those moments are not without interest, as Tania Modleski made clear in her essential The Women Who Knew Too Much, the Agatha Christieing grows wearisome. Solution: Mary, the German-language version Hitch directed a year later which comes in 20 blessed minutes shorter. Murder! B+/Mary A-minus.

The Man Who Knew Too Much (1934) - Not much to say about this expert thriller which put Hitch on the international map except to note that the one sequence that stayed with me since I saw the film as a child was the throwing of the chairs in the church. And if you're in the market for a ripoff of this film starring Joan Crawford, then check out the fun, underrated Above Suspicion (Richard Thorpe, 1943). A-minus

The Lady Vanishes (1938) - I still think there's far too much narrative throat clearing here. They don't get on the train until 27 minutes in. After that, though, the superlative train film. A-minus

Young and Innocent (1937) - I've always preferred this underpraised entry because the wrong man business starts up almost immediately. Other selling points: a car falling into the earth reminding me of my beloved Pandora and the Flying Dutchman (Albert Lewin, 1951); a children's party used to camouflage the wrong man; a dexterous tracking shot as astonishing as the one in Notorious (1946); and the formation of the heterosexual couple as a blissfully tacked-on afterthought much like the one in Secret Agent (and, indeed, most of his films of this era). A-minus

Rich and Strange (1931) - The most accurately named film in Hitch's oeuvre. A middle-class couple living a life of quiet desperation come into some money. They get drunk in France, sail to Singapore, fall in love with other people, get swindled, lose their money, survive a shipwreck, unwittingly eat a cat [sic], and finally return to their lives of quiet desperation, bickering during the final fade out. It comes off as a parody of not just coupledom but of narrative itself. It's so uncharacteristic, so deeply peculiar that I'm probably overrating it but it hypnotized me. A

The 39 Steps (1935) - Positively choked with implausibilities and I adore every single one of them. This is the quintessential Brit Hitch film complete with modern morality and an understanding of the city as both as a place of horror and refuge. Not even ten minutes in and Annabella Smith (Lucie Mannheim) is going home with Richard Hannay (Robert Donat) mere nanoseconds after they first meet. The scene in which Hannay is mistaken for a politician and rushed on stage to deliver a speech is both hilarious and nail-biting. And one of the most moving sequences in all of Hitch is the young farm wife Margaret (Peggy Ashcroft) asking Hannay about London and dreaming of a life beyond the brutal old crofter she's saddled with. A

Sabotage (1936) - The only thing potentially keeping this from an A+ is the apparent imperative of undercover detective Ted Spencer (John Loder) having to fall in love with the heroine Mrs. Verloc (Sylvia Sidney), a drawback Hitch himself mourned. Even there, though, the requisite formation of the heterosexual couple hardly feels celebratory at the end. In fact, the end proves that Mrs. Verloc gets away with murder, however emotionally justified. Sabotage takes the best qualities of The 39 Steps and amps them further. It's a great city film akin to, albeit slightly inferior to, M (Fritz Lang, 1931). And, perhaps perversely, its investigation of the space around the central location, a well-attended movie theatre, reminds me of Parade (Jacques Tati, 1974). As such, Sabotage is truly a cinemagoer's delight as Hitchcock explores the ticket booth, the area behind the screen, the living quarters upstairs, the aisles flanking the theatre seats, etc. Another reference point: Porn Theatre (La chatte à deux têtes) (Jacques Nolot, 2002). And his camera visits myriad other locations around the city, a perfect compliment to the restless pace of urban life. All that and quite possibly the nastiest death in his entire oeuvre, one so horrifying that even Hitch himself was upset about it. A

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, April 22, 2020

My ten favorite middlebrow films!

This was tough! Lots of second guessing. Can Mike Leigh and Ken Loach possibly be middlebrow? Powell/Pressburger? Michael Mann? John Boorman? I judged Suddenly, Last Summer and Pandora and the Flying Dutchman as finally too wacky to be included. I tried to avoid great directors thus leaving off Ford and Preminger. But I think I chose wisely with Minnelli and Hitchcock. I loved The Dresser (Peter Yates, 1983) as a kid but haven’t seen it since. My favorite Ingmar Bergmans tend to be his least middlebrow (The Silence, Persona, Hour of the Wolf). I’ve seen precious little Kurosawa. Etc.

1. The Queen (Stephen Frears, 2006)
2. Amadeus (Milos Forman, 1984)
3. The Holly and the Ivy (George More O’Ferrall, 1952)
4. Yolanda and the Thief (Vincente Minnelli, 1945)
5. Cast Away (Robert Zemeckis, 2000)
6. Under Capricorn (Alfred Hitchcock, 1949)
7. Diabolique (aka Les diaboliques) (Henri-Georges Clouzot, 1955)
8. Victim (Basil Dearden, 1961)
9. Quills (Philip Kaufman, 2000)
10. 8 1/2 (Federico Fellini, 1963)




Labels: , , ,

Monday, September 30, 2019

Under Capricorn (Alfred Hitchcock, 1949)

The problem with Under Capricorn isn't that it's not a suspense film; it's that it doesn't work by Hitchcock's dictum about suspense. The audience needs more information, not less, to feel suspense. Here, we don't know why Lady Henrietta (Ingrid Bergman) has become an alcoholic until the climax of the film. In fact, the Wikipedia plot synopsis is incorrect because it tries to work by Hitchcock's dictum in having Lady Henrietta reveal the plot twist well before she actually does (and to the wrong person). So it fails the classical Hollywood requirement of clear motivations and consistent character traits. BUT. That just means this is a de facto art film. You can *feel* the suffocation with Hitchcock's astonishing long takes, each the equivalent of holding your breath for several minutes. It's a film that demands at least a second viewing to reveal its tense pleasures. And many of the Hitch hallmarks are present - the doubled couples, the female Oedipal trajectory, the repression, etc.

Labels:

Waltzes from Vienna (Alfred Hitchcock, 1934)

Waltzes from Vienna centers on the agitated artistic temperament of Johann "Schani" Strauss II in Oedipal revolt against Strauss père. Jessie Matthews (star of that quasi-oxymoronic genre - the British film musical) is on hand to prevent Schani from pursuing his muse by forcing him to work in her father's bakery. One memorable scene has "The Blue Danube" being composed to the rhythms of bakers making bread. It's actually more solid than something like The Paradine Case (1947). But unlike that one, there's not much personality in it and it's ultimately forgettable. If you haven't seen, oh I don't know, Saboteur (1942), you should probably do that first. But this one causes little pain.

Labels: ,

To Catch a Thief (Alfred Hitchcock, 1955)

So what's Alfred Hitchcock's worst film of the 1950s (the period most critics/scholars deem his greatest decade)? I used to think it was the meringue-stuffed To Catch a Thief (1955). But having just watched it again for the first time in eons, I'm struck by its pungent view of the wealthy. If the film feels inert compared to the masterpieces surrounding it, then that's because it's primarily about rich people courting danger in the face of being so bored with all their money. In this respect, the most important character is neither Cary Grant nor Grace Kelly; it's the crass, bourbon-swilling, nouveau riche widow Jessie (Jessie Royce Landis, one of dozens of actors who gave Hitch's films so much of their depth) who's cool with her jewels being stolen since she'll be reimbursed by John Williams' beleaguered insurance man. It just might be Hitchcock's most trenchant take on class. Other positives (apart from the famous fireworks): the dollar-green night scenes, the gorgeous location shooting, Cary Grant cruising man flesh, and a typically brilliant final shot which knocks the stuffing out of the requisite heterosexual coupling. So what IS Hitch's worst film of the 1950s?

Labels:

Friday, January 12, 2018

Best Films of 2017

10. Division Movement to Vungtau (Benjamin Crotty and Bertrand Dezoteux)
These enfants terribles dishonor 16mm footage sourced from the US National Archives of off-duty American soldiers in Vietnam c. 1966-1968 by inserting motion-captured anthropomorphic fruit. To quote Phil Coldiron in a dead-on summation for The Brooklyn Rail, "the pair throw stink bombs into...the boomer nostalgia that marks Vietnam as more than just another catastrophe in our idiot nation’s storied history of them" and, as such, would make a perfect coda to Ken Burns' The Vietnam War.
9. Tonsler Park (Kevin Jerome Everson)
An 80-minute observation at a polling precinct in Charlottesville, Virginia on November 8th, 2016 of the black bodies our legislatures are gerrymandering out of existence.
8. The Florida Project (Sean Baker)
With many parking lots to cross, the barely working poor at a motel in Anywhere, USA find no relief from noise, heat, and the fitfully sympathetic management.
7. The Death of Louis XIV (Albert Serra)
Not a requiem but rather an ode to cinema's embalming function. I see dead people indeed.
6. Ismael's Ghosts (director's cut) (Arnaud Desplechin)
24 Hour Psycho Back and Forth and To and Fro (Douglas Gordon)
Hitchcock is always with us. Desplechin retells Vertigo as four films in one for the ADD set while Gordon's 2008 installation (at the 21st St. Gagosian through February 3rd) features one 24-hour Psycho running forward while another adjoining one runs backward. I haven't had so much fun at a gallery-cum-cinema, well, ever! My friend Bill and I were like giddy children before this monument to a lifetime of close readings. "Wait - wasn't Vera Miles walking backwards away from the house at one point?" "Do you know the name of the actor who played the cop?" "Man, he held this shot a long time." "Let's stay to see Ted Knight!"
 
5. Zama (Lucretia Martel)
A welcome and criminally tardy return of the genius Martel for a tale about a victim of hope winding his way through various disorienting spaces, the most terrifying pictured below from a brief moment I won't soon forget.
4. Baby Driver (Edgar Wright)
Finally - a big-budget Hollywood action film/box-office smash I loved! And a far better musical than La La Land. I can't even: Ansel Elgort.
3. On Generation and Corruption (Takashi Makino)
Makino takes Maya Deren's concept of vertical editing to unprecedented depths as you dive into his blizzard of superimpositions.
2. Sleep Has Her House (Scott Barley)
So gorgeous, so uncompromising that I actually wept at the end. Sleep Has Her House evokes Edward Steichen's eerie Moonlight photos or maybe The Turin Horse devoid of humans. You can scarcely imagine the profilmic events Barley encountered even though the film was presumably shot on this planet. As of this writing and for shame, Sleep Has Her House has yet to have its New York (or even North American!) premiere.
1. SPF-18 (Alex Israel)
In a year when cinema kept dying and Twin Peaks: The Return was a film (or not), and streaming threatened the thingishness of things, SPF-18 suggests that such epistemological uncertainty is the natural order of art. This is a film alright. But it's also part of a multi-platform project comprised of, to quote the VIA Art Fund's sober description, "a feature-length film, soundtrack, artwork, digital outreach program, and accompanying high school curriculum." Apparently, Israel toured high schools with the film although I've yet to uncover evidence that this actually happened and any documentation thereof would compete with the film as a primary aesthetic object. The film features cameos by Keanu Reeves, Molly Ringwald, Rosanna Arquette, Pamela Anderson, and Goldie Hawn (as the narrator), a 1980s soundtrack including hits from Duran Duran, The Cars, and Yaz, several of Isreal's art works, and some of the most ridiculous aerial shots ever filmed. It's basically an after-school special about the need for beautiful teenagers to follow their creative muse. I have absolutely no clue how to position myself with respect to this thing and I imagine further inquiries into Israel's access and privilege will force my mind in one firm direction. But for now, this was the most head-spinning encounter with cinema (or whatever) I had all year. SPF-18 is available on Netflix as of this writing. Watch it, kay?


Labels: ,

Friday, August 12, 2016

Hitchcock/Truffaut (Kent Jones, 2015)

If you've never read Hitchcock/Truffaut, the 1966 book of interviews with the Master of Suspense, then you'll get great mileage out of Kent Jones' documentary about the legendary encounter. Like any film geek worth their weight in external hard drives, I read it damn near daily in my formative years. With its copious frame enlargements, mountains of trivia (including a list of all of Hitch's cameos!), and deep insights, it was a drop of water on the desert of film scarcity. And so the documentary had only mild use value for me. I knew the requisite analyses of Vertigo and Psycho were coming. And it's not as if those sections were without deep insights of their own, particularly Scorsese on the necessity of the blandness of the early office scene in Psycho (to give the viewer a sense of security before the shock of dispensing with Marion so early in the film). But damn - how many people interested in this documentary don't know those films to death? How about an exploration of the greatness of Family Plot? Or a test of Truffaut's contention that the worst film of Hitchcock's is more interesting than the best film of Delannoy's by pitting Waltzes from Vienna against This Special Friendship?

Even more problematic is how blandly Jones tells this tale. One of the most useful insights from the Hitchcock/Truffaut book is "ventilating the play," the film director's (usually doomed) attempt to open out a stage play's limited scenery. Most creators of documentaries rely too much on the inherent fascination of their subjects to carry their films. Thus, the filmmakers either neglect to attend to matters of form or resort to dead end attempts to give their subjects some motion. Jones' film betrays all the hoary trademarks of the genre - talking heads, zooms into still images/movie posters, explanatory text, etc. As with so many similar projects, it would have worked just as well as an essay or an illustrated blog post.

Still, Hitchcock/Truffaut is worth a viewing for the portrait of the warm friendship that developed between the two. Hitch knew his films were masterpieces and Truffaut's reaching out to him was the validation he deserved at long last. Most touching of all, then, are the images of the letters they sent to one another in the last decade of Hitch's filmmaking life. They keep up on each other's new films, they ask each other advice, and it all brings a tear to the eye, just like Truffaut's initial request for an interview did to Hitch's.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Stephen Rebello's Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of Psycho

Well after taking in Hitchcock (Sacha Gervasi, 2012), I finally caught up with Stephen Rebello's Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of Psycho, the book on which the film...well, actually, had I read Manohla Dargis' NY Times review before watching, I'd have known that the film is only tangentially related to the book. It pretzels up some facts and centers much of the dramatic energy on a blossoming affair between Hitchcock's wife Alma Reville and screenwriter Whitfield Cook, a story which gets no play in Rebello's tight historical account of Psycho's controversial journey to screen. That leaves Gervasi's film a fun but rather empty exercise. Rebello's book is much more useful while never stinting on the fun. So below are the choicest quotes therein starting with a knockout simile concerning the media storm surrounding Ed Gein, the Wisconsin murderer who inspired Robert Bloch's 1959 novel on which Hitchcock's 1960 masterpiece was based.


The press and the ambulance chasers attached themselves to Plainfield like piranha on a drowning sumo wrestler.


In private Hitchcock railed. To the public he made light, as when he told the New York Times about his frustration in finding suitable material: “Newspaper headlines tell too many outlandish stories from real life that drive the spinner of suspense fiction to further extremes. I always regard the fact that we’ve got to outwit the audience to keep them with us. They’re highly trained detectives looking at us out there right now.”


Stefano perceived that the way to engage Hitchcock's imagination was to conceptualize and verbalize the story in terms of visuals. According to Stefano, "He was not interested in characters or motivation at all. That was the writer's job. If I said, 'I'd like to give the girl an air of desperation,' he'd say, 'Fine, fine.' But when I said, 'In the opening of the film, I'd like a helicopter shot over the city, then go right up to the seedy hotel where Marion is spending her lunch hour with Sam,' he said, 'We'll go right into the window!' That sort of thing excited him."


Once Hitchcock and Stefano had completed the breakdown, it was all over but the shooting. "We had lunch and toasted the project with champagne," said Stefano. "He looked very sad, and said, 'The picture's over. Now I have to go and put it on film.'"


After the director had arranged a private showing of Vertigo at the writer’s request, Stefano believed he had at last glimpsed the man who hid behind the mask. “Here was this incredibly beautiful movie he had made that nobody went to see or said nice things about it," Stefano said. “I told him I thought it was his best film. It brought him to near-tears."


Only Dean Stockwell strikes one as a viable alternative [to Perkins].


Miles remained philosophical about losing the chance for stardom in Vertigo. “Hitchcock got his picture," she said. "I got a son."

Stefano and Hitchcock had deliberately layered-in certain risqué elements as a ruse to divert the censors from more crucial concerns: primarily the action that took place in the shower and bathroom.


“Wimpy” was used as a substitute moniker for all in-house communications regarding the film. The story perhaps stems from the fact that the name of the second-unit cameraman on the picture, Rex Wimpy, appeared on clapboards and production sheets, and hence in some on-the-set stills for Psycho.


"We did between fourteen to eighteen setups a day, which, for a major motion picture director, is a lot."


Hitchcock suppressed any synopsis of the plot for public consumption. No other director had done this since Cecil B. DeMille on The Ten Commandments.  [Is this a joke? Don't we already know the story?]


Bass: " By modern standards, we don't think that represents staccato cutting because we've gotten so accustomed to flashcuts. But to have, in those days - I don't know what it was, two minutes, three minutes, whatever the sequence ran? - forty or sixty cuts, whatever it might be -was just a very new idea stylistically. As a title person, it was a very natural thing to use that quick-cutting, montage technique to deliver what amounted to an impressionistic, rather than a linear, view of the murder."

On-set wardrobe supervisor Rita Riggs elaborated about stand-in Marli Renfro and her director: "Because of makeup, of course, the model could not wear even a robe. But she became so comfortable, I recall her sitting quite nude except for this crazy little patch we always put over the pubic hair, talking with Mr. Hitchcock."


Hitchcock, throughout his career, maintained a healthy irreverence toward the guardians of law and order, and his view of Arbogast - smug, glib, tenacious, slightly dull - is no exception. In film after film, Hitchcock challenges his audiences to cry out "Why don't the hero and heroine go straight to the police?" Because, implies Hitchcock in answer, all that they will find is a universe of Milton Arbogasts. As the director so often put it, "Logic is dull."


Hitchcock and his screenwriter knew that the [headshrinker-explains-all] scene, the bane of creative types, was “obligatory”: a chance for the audience to catch its collective breath while the “logic” buffs among them got their fill of the facts.


"I still thought it would be clever to have a male voice reading the lines [of Mrs. Bates], which is why I suggested Paul Jasmin to Hitch,” Perkins said. Jasmin, then twenty-three, a Montana-born budding actor who stormed Hollywood with hopes of becoming the next Montgomery Clift or Gary Cooper, was a natural mimic, a practical joker, and a friend of Perkins.


“I was studying to be an actor,” recalled Jasmin."I did this old-lady character named 'Eunice Ayers,' a no-bullshit, Marjorie Main kind of gal. Tony [Perkins] and [Broadway and film star] Elaine Stritch used to egg me on, so I’d call up big stars like Rosalind Russell and put her on with this voice for hours. Stanley Kubrick was directing Spartacus at Universal at the time and, through a press agent, he heard about our little pranks, loved them, and began to tape the conversations. Then, Tony told Hitchcock about me and gave him some of the tapes.”

Labels: ,

Monday, May 07, 2012

Queering Cary Grant

As if he needed any help. But here he is in Suspicion (Alfred Hitchcock, 1941).

Werk!

Labels: , ,